Life On A DIR Planet
By Brendan O'Brien
What is DIR? It's a way of making yourself a better diver but, as Brendan
O'Brien explains, it isn't for everyone.
DIR? So what's all that about then?
|DIR stands for Doing it Right, not to be confused
with "Doing the Right Thing", "There's a Right Way
and Wrong Way" or "Two Wrongs Don't Make a Right".
I still don't get it.
|It's simple really. A small group of divers
scattered across the world believe that there is only one way to dive,
and that's the DIR way.
The DIR way? Are you trying to say I've been diving all
this time the DIW way - Doing it Wrong?
|Well, not quite Doing it Wrong - you've just
not been Doing it Right.
|DIR is simple enough. It involves a "system
comprising of a Unified Team, Enhanced Dive Preparation and the DIR
Equipment Configuration", or at least, that's how DIR guru Jarrod
Jablonski of the GUE describes it.
|Oh yes, I forgot to mention, DIR divers love
TLAs? I wish you'd stop that!
|TLAs, you know - Three Letter Abbreviations.
The DIR Dictionary is full of new words and some rather big ones that
have been around for years. GUE stands for Global Underwater Explorers.
Here's a few examples for you: dirQuest is an online magazine, and
"Hogarthian Configuration" is, well, the Hogarthian way
of configuring equipment. It's all part of a new and exciting line
Hogarthian Configuration? Sounds like formation diving.
|Not quite. The Hogarthian Configuration is
actually the predecessor to DIR, named after Bill Hogarth Main, one
of the first technical divers to explore the North Florida caves of
the Woodville Karst Plain back in the '80s.
I kind of like Hogarthian. Why did they change it?
|I guess it just wasn't TLA enough, and you
know what these technical divers are like; they wouldn't want to be
confused with the rest of the diving community. Lots of TLAs set you
apart from the norm.
Hence DIR, implying that everyone else is DIW?
|When you see phrases like "the greatest
barrier to a DIR Planet" and "preach the gospel [of DIR]"
on their website, it does make you wonder.
So what's in it for us, besides accepting that one day
we'll all have to dive the DIR way on a DIR Planet?
|Actually, it all makes sense. The "Unified
Team" stresses the need for teamwork beyond the normal buddy-to-buddy
relationship, "Enhanced Preparation" advocates better dive
planning and "DIR Configuration" is about taking on the
dive only what you need and nothing else. So standard BCs are out,
as are conventional octopus rigs.
Leave my BC and octopus? Are they crazy?
|They're a progressive bunch, this DIR lot.
They figure that conventional BCs just aren't streamlined enough and
that the standard octopus is impractical for use in an emergency.
Decades of cave-diving have taught them a few things about what's
needed and what isn't.
What does cave-diving have to do with conventional sport-diving?
|DIR divers believe that if it works in the
confines of a cave, it's equally valid in any other open-water situation.
One of the greatest challenges to equipment configuration comes in
the DIR practice of donating air to your buddy from your own regulator
in an out-of-air situation.
Isn't that what an octopus is for?
|Have you ever tried to release an octopus from
one of those little fluorescent mouthpiece-holders? And then breathe
comfortably from it while trying to control an ascent, and getting
up close and personal with the donor because of the short hose? It's
a great idea in theory but a pain in the neck in practice. And if
the donor hasn't secured his octopus somewhere, you can guarantee
that you'll grab one full of seaweed and sand.
DIR equipment configuration and techniques are based on the assumption
that the first breath you need in an emergency must be from a regulator
guaranteed to provide air. The donor will have just taken a breath
from his regulator so it's a safe bet that it will work. DIR divers
suggest that in most out-of-air situations the diver in need will
go for the donor's regulator, whatever their training.
Sounds interesting, tell me more.
|The donor's regulator is attached to a long
hose of about 1.5 to 2m, reducing the prospect of getting too close
in an emergency situation. DIR divers believe this provides more room
to manoeuvre. Once the out-of-air diver has the donor's main regulator,
the donor uses a reserve regulator on a shorter hose.
They might have something there. Anything else?
|A lot more, actually. If you want to be DIR,
you'd better shape up!
|I'm talking about proper shaping-up, not just
with your kit but physically and mentally. If you want to be part
of the DIR gang you need to be mentally prepared, with lots of focus.
The DIR doors are closed to any diving slobs, so you'd better lose
that curry spare tyre. They'd see you as a liability to yourself and
You mean they'd want me to give up the night-before-the-dive
korma, five pints of lager and twenty fags?
|It looks that way, and while you're at it,
that new C-card you've just collected is DIR-worthless.
I'll have you know they cost a fortune in the Caribbean!
Between pool-training and diving in crystal-clear water, that qualification
didn't come easy.
|DIR divers view any qualifications simply as
evidence of reaching a minimum standard. That's when the real learning
starts. Experience counts for everything on a DIR Planet. If you don't
have the experience, you can't join them.
Isn't that a bit of a Catch 22?
|Not really, they just feel that a certification
card isn't a passport to advanced technical diving. Lots of experience
and evidence of plenty of work-up dives will impress a DIR diver a
lot more than your badge collection.
Sounds like DIR is just another word for elitism and machismo.
|Elite? Maybe. Macho? Probably not. The Unified
Team approach demands that if you don't feel you're up for a dive
for any reason, you say so. The DIR way doesn't allow for name-calling.
If you think a dive is beyond your capabilities, or if you feel uncomfortable
for any reason, all you need to do is tell the others and your decision
will be accepted by the rest of the team. In fact, by being so honest
and humble you'll probably go up a notch in their estimation.
So much for challenging the diving limits, then?
|It's a weird one. I guess it's all about the
confidence to know what you're capable of. Phrases like "Just
dive in at the deep end" and "Go on, have a go" aren't
in the DIR dictionary. It's all about looking after your team-mates
as well as yourself. Creating that balance of diving safely and stretching
the limits at the same time.
So I need to lose some weight, get fit, cut out the lager,
stop smoking, start planning dives with a bit more thought for my team-mates,
lose my BC and get a long hose for my main regulator. Don't want much,
|It doesn't end there. DIR is viewed as a holistic
system, almost a way of life - miss one part out and it's just not
DIR. You'll need to get rid of all that fancy clobber you've bought
over the years and adopt the minimalist DIR approach. Every piece
of equipment should complement the other.
Not my brand new day-glo BC and matching fins?
|You need to replace your BC with a rigid backplate
of stainless steel or aluminium, get yourself a webbed harness and
a back-mounted BC. The rules are very strict. Buying a twin-set, a
black drysuit and a BC full of D-rings doesn't make you a DIR diver.
It all sounds a bit fanatical.
|No way! How many divers do you know who are
fanatical or obsessive? Whatever made you think that?
OK, so how do you go about finding the residents of Planet
|Good question. They're still pretty much an
unknown factor in diving, scattered across the globe in small cells.
Communication seems to be via the DIR Internet chat forums. Even then,
it's easy to be castigated if you try to suggest anything that isn't
DIR. Feedback the DIR way comes in the form of stressing that somebody
is "the antithesis of DIR and I'd be afraid of getting into the
water with you".
They sound a bit touchy.
|With good reason. Take Benji of Bonaire, a
true martyr for the DIR cause.
What, he lost his life for DIR?
|Not quite, but he was fired as a diving instructor
for refusing to change his DIR ways. Apparently, his non-DIR PADI
boss didn't share his fondness for long hoses and love of stainless
steel. It didn't fit into the Doing It All Over The World way of the
Poor Benji. He gave up his career so people like us could
dive the DIR way!
|Steady on! He got the sack for trying to teach
what wasn't on the syllabus and for wearing strange diving equipment
instead of being a PADI role model.
Ah! But all it takes for evil to succeed is for good men
to do nothing, and all that stuff.
|I think you're getting a little carried away
Sorry, he reminded me of history's lost causes. Perhaps
because of people like Benji we'll all be diving the DIR way some day.
|You're always latching on to the latest fads.
Underwater photography, technical diving, free-diving... you're so
Me? Are you saying this is just another diving fad?
|I'm sure you're quite capable of making up
your own mind.
So if DIR is here to stay, what should I say if I talk
|Ask about the length of their hoses, aluminium
or stainless steel, the size of their tanks, gas mixes. Don't say:
"SMBs, who needs them!", "Do you like my new pink fins?"
or "Fancy a beer?"